Welcome to 11 Oak Lane, a rare West Tisbury offering that lives as a true Martha's Vineyard family compound, an income-producing investment, or both. Set on 2.7 private acres, the property has been meticulously maintained and recently updated from the systems up, giving you the flexibility to gather generations under one address, live in one home and rent the other, or simply enjoy an exceptional single-family residence.
The main home is a single-story 3-bedroom, 3-bath with a private primary suite wing featuring an ensuite bath, glass shower, and Jacuzzi tub. The open kitchen, dining, and living areas flow into bright, light-filled gathering spaces with cherry hardwood floors, granite countertops, radiant heat, and central A/C. The roof, mechanical systems, and finishes have all been recently updated. Downstairs, the fully finished lower level adds tremendous versatility, with room for a home gym, an office, a playroom, or all of the above.
A short walk across the lawn, the one-bedroom accessory apartment sits above its own garage with a separate private entrance, full kitchen, full bath, outdoor shower, and patio. It's an ideal setup for extended family, long-term guests, or rental income.
Then there's the two-story storage structure, an extraordinary flex space with workshop, studio, or creative-use potential. A basketball court, two sheds, and ample parking on a separate driveway round out the offering.
All of it sits minutes from Lamberts Cove Beach, Cronig's Market, the West Tisbury Post Office, and both the West Tisbury and Charter Schools, with quick access up and down island.
Family compound. Income property. Forever home. 11 Oak Lane is ready for whatever chapter comes next.
Property highlights
Unfurnished
Public Beach
Patio
Porch
Septic Tank
Cable
Well Water
Property Details
Association Fee:
Association Fee Includes:
Basement:
Full & Finished
Fireplace Features:
0
Flooring:
Cherry Hardwood
Foundation Types:
Poured concrete
Frontage Type:
None
Heating:
OFHA
Interior Features:
AC,Ins,Irr,OShFloor 1: Kitchen, Dining room, Living room, Primary suite, 2 guest bedrooms, full bathroom, mud room & laundry, stairs to the finished lower level
Link MLS Comments:
Take Old County Road to Oak Lane. First property on the right. Owners are in residence.
Lot Features:
Expansive lawn with irrigation
Parking Features:
Ample parking on two separate driveways: a large drive for the main house, plus a dedicated entrance and drive for the accessory apartment and two-story storage structure.
Possible Use:
Assessed Building Value:
1341500.00
Assessed Land Value:
726900.00
Price History
May 09, 2026
$2,250,000
Tax Information
This property was most recently assessed in 2026. It has been assessed at a value of $2,068,400. The annual tax responsibility for this property is $9,200.